It’s not common for a team to lose 110 games, as the Diamondbacks just did. Indeed, in the National League, the only other side to do so in the past fifty years, were... the 2004 Diamondbacks. This obviously merits comparison. How did the two teams manage this unwanted feat? Did they go about achieving an abject level of suckage the same way, or were there different approaches taken? There were some aspects where I was particularly struck by the similarities - yet in other areas, the disparity was equally marked. But before we take a deeper dive into the seasons, let’s take a look at how things got to the point where the two teams stood on Opening Day.
2004 vs. 2021
|Departures||Raul Mondesi||Junior Guerra|
|Mike Myers||Jon Jay|
|Miguel Batista||Mike Leake|
|Curt Schilling||Hector Rondon|
|Chris Capuano||Silvino Bracho|
|Craig Counsell||Kevin Cron|
|Jorge De La Rosa|
|Arrivals||Elmer Dessens||Tyler Gilbert|
|Casey Fossum||Joakim Soria|
|Brandon Lyon||Tyler Clippard|
|Richie Sexson||Humberto Castellanos|
|Shane Nance||Asdrubal Cabrera|
|Roberto Alomar||Bryan Holaday|
The 2004 team were clearly coming off a better season. Though they finished sixteen games back of the 100-win Giants, they were only seven behind the wild-card Marlins. While that 84-win campaign was fourteen down on 2002, Arizona were one of six teams in the National League to finish in the 83-87 win range. You didn’t have to squint too hard to see a path back to relevance. GM Joe Garagiola Jr. didn’t mess around, making a lot of changes - two in particular stand out.
One was the departure of Curt Schilling for Boston. The pitcher was in the final year of his contract, and had gone 8-9 with a 2.95 ERA in the 2003 season. I think it’s safe to say, this one worked out considerably better for the Red Sox, being a key factor in letting them win their first World Series in 86 years. There was no SnakePit in those days, so we can’t assess fan sentiment at the time. But it seems odd for a team that wanted to content, dealing an ace like Schilling for... Mike Goss (who never reached the majors), Casey Fossum, Brandon Lyon and Jorge De La Rosa. Even with just a year of team control, that feels like a very light return.
Just three days later, the team pulled the trigger on the other trade, which saw half a team go to the Brewers: Chris Capuano, Craig Counsell, Chad Moeller, Lyle Overbay, the newly-arrived Jorge De La Rosa and Junior Spivey. Conversely, that seems a very HEAVY price for one season of control, even of an All-Star like Richie Sexson. Okay, the D-backs also got Shane Nance and the wonderfully-named Noochie Varner - but you’d be hard-pushed to claim either moved the needle on the deal much. For comparison, in 2003 Sexson was worth 3.2 bWAR, a win and a half less than Schilling’s 4.7 bWAR production, even though Curt missed two weeks with an appendectomy and six more after breaking his hand.
To replace Schilling, the team opted to bring in a slew of journeyman starters, opting for depth over ace-iness. The team still had Randy Johnson and Brandon Webb. and rounded out the rotation with Elmer Dessens, knuckleballer Steve Sparks and Shane Reynolds. With a 1-2 like Johnson/Webb, it’s possible to squint and see how that could have seemed like it might have worked. On offense, alongside Sexson, the team signed future trivia answer (“Who was the first Diamondback player to make it into the Hall of Fame?”) Roberto Alomar to a $1 million deal. They had an Opening Day payroll of $70.2 million, which is $126.7 million in 2021 value, when adjusted for baseball inflation.
In comparison, the Diamondbacks after 2020 were much more restrained. That was despite the team finishing in the cellar of the NL West. It had been a weird season, the schedule truncated to 60 games due to COVID-19. GM Mike Hazen felt that the 25-35 record posted was not a true reflection of team talent. They had a winning record 40% of the way through the season, but then imploded, losing eighteen of the next twenty games. Outside that stretch, the D-backs went 23-17. The team had seen the departures of Archie Bradley, Andrew Chafin and Starling Marte at the trade deadline. But few if any of the end-of-season departures could be said to have had a significant impact on the 2021 team.
The team made some moderate free-agent signings. Utility infielder Asdrubal Cabrera signed an incentive heavy $1.75 million deal, with over a million more in potential bonuses. And the team added veteran bullpen arms Joakim Soria ($3.5 million, plus another million in incentives - and a hotel suite on road trips) and Tyler Clippard ($2.25 million guaranteed, including a $500K buyout for 2022). These relievers followed the standard Hazen pattern, of signing veterans with closing experience who were not current closers. Both men had posted 30-save seasons in their careers. But in general, the team was looking for bounce-back seasons from the likes of Ketel Marte and Eduardo Escobar to drive improvement.
Below, you’ll find a table listing the Opening Day rosters for both clubs. Note: for 2004, this is an approximation since I couldn’t find any explicit listing of that information. There is also an extra spot on the 2021 team, with it now being a 26-man roster. Looking at these, who would you have said was the better (or worse!) team?
2004/2021 Opening Day Rosters
|C||Brent Mayne||Carson Kelly|
|!B||Richie Sexson||Christian Walker|
|2B||Roberto Alomar||Eduardo Escobar|
|SS||Alex Cintron||Nick Ahmed|
|3B||Shea Hillenbrand||Asdrubal Cabera|
|OF||Luis Gonzalez||David Peralta|
|OF||Steve Finley||Ketel Marte|
|OF||Danny Bautista||Pavin Smith|
|Bench1||Bobby Estallela||Stephen Vogt|
|Bench2||Matt Kata||Josh Rojas|
|Bench3||Carlos Baerga||Josh VanMeter|
|Bench4||Greg Colbrunn||Tim Locastro|
|Bench5||Donnie Sadler||Wyatt Mathisen|
|SP1||Randy Johnson||Madison Bumgarner|
|SP2||Brandon Webb||Merrill Kelly|
|SP3||Elmer Dessens||Riley Smith|
|SP4||Casey Daigle||Taylor Widener|
|SP5||Steve Sparks||Luke Weaver|
|RP1||Matt Mantei||Joakim Soria|
|RP2||Jose Valverde||Stefan Crichton|
|RP3||Mike Koplove||Kevin Ginkel|
|RP4||Oscar Villarreal||Yoan Lopez|
|RP5||Andrew Good||Chris Devenski|
|RP6||Stephen Randolph||Taylor Clarke|
|RP7||Randy Choate||Caleb Smith|
Next time, we’ll take a look at the overall performance of the two teams from a high level, and figure out how they both reached 110 losses.