/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/55032187/690300468.0.jpg)
Summary
- 42 bad calls in total, averaging 6.0 per game. That’s the lowest figure this season, and there seemed to be a decline in outrageously bad calls too. This doesn’t necessarily indicate the umpires are getting “better”, it could be tied to equipment calibration.
- With the exception of one game, this was entirely a road week, and for the first time, the calls there were basically even, at 19-18 in favor of helping the D-backs. There was still a home bias, however, with a 4-1 margin at Chase Field.
- The totals for the year
Overall: 194-225 (46.3% favor the D-backs)
Home: 115-109 (51.3%)
Road: 79-116 (40.5%) - Both home and road split tilted back towards Arizona as a result, but the overall ratio still skews against the Diamondbacks. That’s particularly true away from Chase where three out of every five bad calls goes against Arizona.
- Best-called game: May 30, 3-0 @ PIT (Eric Cooper). Robbie Ray was not the only person to have a really good night, as home-plate umpire Cooper was tagged with only two bad calls - and one of those was not confirmed from a second source, so it may have been even better.
- Worst-called game: Angel Herna... Wait, what? He actually called a better than average game, with only five questionable calls? Get out the Crayolas and color me surprised. By far the worst was actually: May 28, 5-9 @ MIL (Lance Barrett). From another source (Fangraphs), here’s his strike-zone (red is called strikes, black is called balls, white is batter swings):
:no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/8608439/chart.jpg)
- Worst confirmed call of the week: Also comes from the same game, and you can easily see it on the chart above, as well as below.
Call helps #Dbacks
— D'backs Strike Zone (@DiamondbacksUmp) May 28, 2017
Ball 3 should be strike 2
Top 1 Nelson vs Lamb
4% call same
3.9in from edge pic.twitter.com/siGWZTeM45
The individual games
May 24, 8-6 vs CHW (Angel Hernandez)
- 5 bad calls (1.72% of pitches)
- 4 help, 1 hurt
- 2 outrageously bad calls
- Bad call score: 440
- Worst call
Call helps #Dbacks
— D'backs Strike Zone (@DiamondbacksUmp) May 24, 2017
Strike 1 should be ball 2
Top 1 Delgado vs Abreu
4% call same
3.9in from edge pic.twitter.com/HRNTpovoBX
May 25, 4-0 @ MIL (Stu Scheurwater)
- 7 bad calls (2.59% of pitches)
- 5 help, 2 hurt
- 1 outrageously bad call
- Bad call score: 588
- Worst call
Call helps #Dbacks
— D'backs Strike Zone (@DiamondbacksUmp) May 26, 2017
Strike 1 should be ball 2
Bot 5 Ray vs Arcia
6% call same
3.4in from edge pic.twitter.com/7ta3fPWerc
May 26, 4-2 @ MIL (Jim Reynolds)
- 3 bad calls (0.99% of pitches)
- 1 help, 2 hurt
- 0 outrageously bad calls
- Bad call score: 256
- Worst call
Call hurts #Dbacks
— D'backs Strike Zone (@DiamondbacksUmp) May 27, 2017
Strike 1 should be ball 2
Top 4 Guerra vs Goldschmidt
10% call same
2.6in from edge pic.twitter.com/YrmOvz7M2R
May 27, 1-6 @ MIL (Greg Gibson)
- 5 bad calls (1.79% of pitches)
- 1 help, 4 hurt
- 2 outrageously bad calls
- Bad call score: 410
- Worst call
Call hurts #Dbacks
— D'backs Strike Zone (@DiamondbacksUmp) May 27, 2017
Strike 1 should be ball 3
Top 2 Anderson vs Fuentes
6% call same
3.9in from edge pic.twitter.com/BKmi5HCBXk
May 28, 5-9 @ MIL (Lance Barrett)
- 12 bad calls (3.95% of pitches)
- 8 help, 4 hurt
- 2 outrageously bad calls
- Bad call score: 996
- Worst call
Call helps #Dbacks
— D'backs Strike Zone (@DiamondbacksUmp) May 28, 2017
Ball 3 should be strike 2
Top 1 Nelson vs Lamb
4% call same
3.9in from edge pic.twitter.com/siGWZTeM45
May 29, 2-4 @ PIT (Adrian Johnson)
- 8 bad calls (2.79% of pitches)
- 3 help, 5 hurt
- 2 outrageously bad calls
- Bad call score: 672
- Worst call
Call hurts #Dbacks
— D'backs Strike Zone (@DiamondbacksUmp) May 29, 2017
Strike 1 should be ball 3
Top 3 Williams vs Goldschmidt
4% call same
3.6in from edge pic.twitter.com/k2DzkzmRyR
May 30, 3-0 @ PIT (Eric Cooper)
- 2 bad calls (0.93% of pitches)
- 1 help, 1 hurt
- 1 outrageously bad calls
- Bad call score: 174
- Worst call
Call helps #Dbacks
— D'backs Strike Zone (@DiamondbacksUmp) May 30, 2017
Ball 1 should be strike 1
Top 4 Nova vs Peralta
0% call same
7.9in from edge pic.twitter.com/i4HCqPue0n