AZ Snakepit: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: The Record of Wrongs: Vanderbilt Commodores

Unsung Hero of the Year

A tight race in the Game of the Year Pittie just went to the monumental comeback against the Pirates in May, which beat out clinching the NLDS by a couple of votes. We now move on to the next award, which is for the Unsung Hero of the Year; the man whose contributions to the team were most significant, yet largely went unnoticed. This eliminates the likes of major-league saves leader, Jose Valverde, Manager of the Year, Bob Melvin, and Cy Young runner-up Brandon Webb. For your consideration, we therefore present the following nominees:

Edgar Gonzalez Only eight NL pitchers both started and relieved in more than ten games, and EdGon was one of them. He was in the rotation at the start of the season, and was bumped to the pen after the return of the Big Unit. He was still occasionally the spot starter of choice, but also performed mop-up duty, pitching in a relief role every inning from the first (following Kim to the mound) to the eleventh. He had his blowout appearances, but only when it didn't matter: the most telling stat is, he didn't lose a game for more than five months. Gonzalez hit the mound 26 times between April 21 and September 23, posting a 7-0 record in that period. He came back to start four times at the end of the season, but perhaps his best performance was July 27th when he retired six consecutive batters during a tied game against Atlanta in the 10th and 11th, allowing Clark to hit a walk-off homer.

Conor Jackson Outside of a dismal April, Jackson was the best hitter on the Diamondbacks team. From May 4 until the end of the year, he hit .300, including a second-half line of .308/.371/.555 - an OPS of .926, which compares favorably with the likes of Helton (.939) and Derrek Lee (.941). But that wasn't enough to get him a regular spot at first-base: he only started 13 games in the last month, with Tony Clark often being preferred. He was generally regarded as being defensively inferior to Clark, but other defensive metrics than errors suggest he was actually as good as, if not better than, the veteran. Jackson was particularly brutal against left-handed pitching, smacking them at a .320 rate, and also helped the team out by playing a game in left-field, against Milwaukee on July 16.

Brandon Lyon Valverde may have got the saves, and be dreaming of a $60 million dollar payout, but his set-up man was virtually as good. Lyon posted an ERA only 0.02 worse than Valverde, while pitching more games and innings too. As a result, Brandon's VORP figure was actually higher than Papa Grandes, 24.0 to 21.6, and Lyon was particularly good in hitter-friendly Chase, where his ERA was a miniscule 1.69. He allowed only one home-run in 42.2 innings at home, and his overall HR/9 rate (0.24) was 3rd best in the majors, among the 212 pitchers with seventy or more innings. He blew only three saves all year, in 39 chances, and finished with 35 holds, most in the major-leagues. He also threw strikes a team-leading 66% of the time, and was a crucial part in Arizona having such a good record in one-run games. If we trade Valverde away, he could easily step into the role, and would likely be just as good.

Bryan Price Coming into the season, our bullpen was regarded as flawed, and our rotation behind Brandon Webb had questionmarks over almost every member. But, by the end of the year, we had the second-best ERA+ in the league, Arizona's 114 just trailing the Cubs 115. With the equal-lowest OPS+ in the NL (89), it's clear that our pitching won us the division, and Price's role in that, while difficult to quantity, has to be appreciated. Much as he did in Seattle, also under Melvin, he has helped craft a top-notch bullpen out of parts no-one really rated. In 2007, playing home games at one of the most hitter-friendly parks, they had an ERA of 3.95. Our top seven relievers by innings pitched were better yet, with a 3.47 ERA over more than 400 innings. But Brandon Webb also improved and Doug Davis had one of the best years in his career, while Yusmeiro Petit and Micah Owings proved better than league-average in their rookie campaigns.

Chris Snyder It was generally expected that this would be the year Miguel Montero took over the reins: Snyder thought otherwise, and earned more starts in August and September than any other month. He had a particularly productive second-half, batting .292 with an .889 OPS, good enough for second in the majors among catchers after the break, better than McCann, Martinez and Martin. But his defense was rock-solid too, with only one error in 106 games, and he threw out 35.8% of base-stealers - a better percentage than Gold Glove winner Russell Martin, and third-best in the league (50 or more games). He also called and caught almost all of Webb and Davis's starts, including the vast majority of the former's 42-innings scoreless streak. He has a lock in the position for Opening Day 2008, and since he's under Arizona control through 2010, promises to be a valuable commodity.

Poll
Who's the unsung hero of the year for AZ?
Edgar Gonzalez
8 votes
Conor Jackson
21 votes
Brandon Lyon
25 votes
Bryan Price
17 votes
Chris Snyder
30 votes

101 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 16 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Great Poll
Boy, this one is a toughie. While I've got to applaud Snyderman for the most unexpected performance, I am casting my vote for Conor. Not an MVP season, but there are fans out there shouting for AZ to re-sign Clark and give Jackson the boot. An OPS of .926 in the second half for a young player is something to really get behind. While Clark would bring a great presence to the clubhouse, I'd rather see us make a commitment to CJ, and let him build on a very solid year.

by Counsellmember on Nov 25, 2007 5:22 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Great
This poll is good. I give my vote for Edgar.

by worlzkyin663 on Nov 26, 2007 12:05 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

Best award yet
I wanted to vote for Conor very badly.  Seemed for a while there I was the only one here that wanted him to stay.  It was also hard to not vote for Lyon, though I think Pena should have been added to this list as well.  He burned out a little, but was just as unexpectedly(?) magnificent.

However, I voted for Snyder.  I think he is one of the top, if not the best, defensive catchers in the NL right now and he hits OK too.  There's a lot to be said for a how a good catcher helps your team and he goes unheralded except for the deeper parts of the fanbase.

Bob Melvin Sucks

by nihil67 on Nov 26, 2007 9:43 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

Got to go to...
for Snyderman. The award is for unsung. How many times have we lauded the bullpen or price? even CoJack gets a bit of lovin and the paramedic was good but not amazing.

Plus...who else has a damn themesong ;)

by Wimb on Nov 26, 2007 3:32 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

conor
I vote for him.  He started hitting the ball hard and pulling it too, no more of those poopy shot putts to short right field.

by kylerkenney on Nov 26, 2007 6:15 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

I went with CoJack
Largely because I didn't realize just how impressive he was, and he spent a lot of time watching Tony Clark get starts.  But a number of good choices available here...
I'm not superstitious- it's bad luck.

by kishi on Nov 26, 2007 6:31 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

I had to go for Snyderman
I do value CoJack and don't understand why he sat so  much at the end of the year.  Clark hit some bombs at the end but he is taking AB's from CoJack.  Let CoJack have the job at 1st.

by DiamondbacksWIn on Nov 26, 2007 9:45 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Beyond much discussed luck and improved
defense, the Dbacks' good fortunes were almost entirely due to an unexpectedly broad-based pitching improvement. Unexpected? Preseason expectations revolved around Randy Johnson; in a tight division, anything good might happen with the old Randy - without him, the consensus was our boyz were goners. So Randy got shelved and Price, Melvin and Byrnes cobbled together the NL's best staff anyway, better than San Diego, the Mets & LA. Nobody saw that coming.  

Broad based? Webb maintained - indeed improved on - his CY performance. Steadily declining, lukewarm commodities Davis and Livan both bettered respective 2006 numbers. Cruz and Valverde both recaptured career best form. They got 150IP of 109 ERA+ from a kid who never pitched in Triple AAA. And no less than three relievers - Lyon, Pena and Slaten - came out of nowhere to add enormous collective value.

Is this all coincidence, or can we assign some overarching credit here, beyond that of the individual pitchers? Josh Byrnes? Bob Melvin? Sure, but Byrnes also oversaw construction of a certifiably icky offense (the one that reminded him of the '66 Orioles last March) and Melvin is no longer unsung. Failure to honor the pitching coach of a team that eked out the league's most wins, ostensibly "supported" by the NL's worst offense, seems an oversight of criminal proportions.

by Diamondhacks on Nov 28, 2007 12:14 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Always with the dramatic
But isn't it nearly impossible for us, as fans not involved with the team, to determine how much of a factor Price was in the performances?  Further, wasn't Price the pitching coach last year too?  That staff wasn't the best in the NL.  The players have to actually go out and perform.

How can you compare coaching to a 1st baseman that was the best hitter on the team in the second half, yet everyone wants traded or cut?  Or compare coaching to a catcher that should have won the gold glove by just about every stat I can find?

Bob Melvin Sucks

by nihil67 on Nov 28, 2007 12:50 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Dramarama: The Sequel
But isn't it nearly impossible for us, as fans not involved with the team, to determine how much of a factor Price was in the performances?

It's impossible to pinpoint - that's why I'm offering the broad-based, circumstantial case for Price instead. Conversely, it's bloody difficult to definitively isolate a player's natural contribution to his own yearly success relative to external influences (ie coaching, luck, PEDs, etc.). We never completely know.

Further, wasn't Price the pitching coach last year too?

This is about 2007, not a weighted lifetime achievement award ;-)

What kind of collective performance would this staff need to have reached to convince you that Price had a significant, positive influence on this oddly inbalanced team's success? What more, beyond the little 114 Team ERA+, is a staff full of no names and retreads - with precious little help from Randy - supposed to do?

That damned Price never maximized JD Durbin!    

The players have to actually go out and perform.

They certainly dont have to go out and perform up to their potential  - the fact is lots of major league players and teams dont. This pitching staff clearly did - and then some.    

Conor Jackson is neither unsung nor a hero. He is one of the more recognizable and popular players and quite "well sung" amongst Valley womenfolk.  Showing steady improvement over three years, heroically honing his craft, Conor has graduated into a lousy offensive first baseman and a lousy defensive first baseman. It is not conspiracy that splits his time with Clark - it's because neither guy is quite good enough to play full time right now - Clark hits lefties better.

Snyder's the only reasonable pick amongst position players, by virtue of his defense and potential impact on the team's golden goose - the staff - but even Chris only played two thirds of the time.

Several pitchers have a decent individual case - the ones Jim nominated - plus Pena who threw 80+ innings, plus Cruz, plus Davis, etc. The problem, for me, is separating these guys out. What does stand out is the bizarrely brilliant, collective performance. That's why I'm going with Price, the quiet antidote to Kevin Seitzer, with a face that many mistake, in one of the club's biggest ironies, for that of Derrick Hall :-)

by Diamondhacks on Nov 28, 2007 6:44 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

correction
Clark hits lefties better.

* scratch that. Clark hits RHP better.  

by Diamondhacks on Nov 28, 2007 6:47 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

What?
[This is about 2007, not a weighted lifetime achievement award ;-)

What kind of collective performance would this staff need to have reached to convince you that Price had a significant, positive influence on this oddly inbalanced team's success? What more, beyond the little 114 Team ERA+, is a staff full of no names and retreads - with precious little help from Randy - supposed to do? ]

No, you've just proven my point.  Same pitching coach, two opposite results.  My argument is that his involvement in both results is impossible to gauge by anyone that isn't one of the pitchers he's coached.

And your condemnation of Jackson continues to prove why he's both unsung and underrated.

Thanks for proving both of those for me.

[Conversely, it's bloody difficult to definitively isolate a player's natural contribution to his own yearly success relative to external influences (ie coaching, luck, PEDs, etc.). We never completely know.]

Huh?  You've lost me on this one.  We can't isolate a player's contribution to his own success?

Bob Melvin Sucks

by nihil67 on Nov 28, 2007 7:01 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

The Price is Right
My argument is that [Price's] involvement in both results is impossible to gauge by anyone that isn't one of the pitchers he's coached.

Surely, it's impossible to know exactly where coaching, talent and luck intersect as drivers of team success, and players have the richest anecdotal experiences with a coach, but to suggest that this intimacy categorically disqualifies the rest of us from estimating a coach's value strikes me as a bit fascist. Just because you reflexively key ill conceived, cocksure rants against Bob Melvin in the face of compelling evidence to the contrary, doesnt mean the rest of us cant apply reason to coaches' performance - armed with full season stats and a little logic.

Granted, we lack the kind of comprehensive inside information to hire or fire a coach from our living rooms, but one need not be in the Player's Union to recognize that the 2007 staff - sans Randy - wildly exceeded expectations. Price may not be responsible for all, or even most, of that - I'm just saying that when 7 or 8 pitchers, journeymen and CY winners, youngsters and veterans, exceed established expectations, that's highly unusual, and is more likely the result of some external influence (ie a coach or new regimen,etc) than it is from 7 or 8 "independent" career years. This "independent event" logic was sufficient to carry the day after a mere 4 months with Kevin Seitzer, why so hostile to it, after a full season, now?  

Same pitching coach, two opposite results. I dont understand what you're trying to establish here. That we shouldn't praise a coach's 2007 impact because his 2006 staff didnt wildly exceed expectations too? What subject could ever be judged fairly under such a bottomless standard and why would we ever apply it, other than to make someone look bad? These are yearly awards, every year is different. Coaches mature and interact dynamically with new personnel. The 2007 results are in and the staff almost singlehandedly dragged this miserable hitting team into the playoffs. I'm trying to account for a remarkable staff performance that, because it was so broad based, defies pure chance (ie 100% dumb luck).  

Re Conor, I dont know what part of "he's a lousy first baseman" you dont understand. This has nothing to do with his salary or age or whether he'll be good in the future, or whether he's a slightly better hitter than someone who can actually catch a ball, like Eric Byrnes or Orlando Hudson. It's about what he hit last year relative to his peer group of defensively limited orcs - starting NL first basemen. Conor hit better than Mike Jacobs and Ryan Klesko and whoever Atlanta had at first, but after adjusting for park and defense, that's about it.

His splits suggest that had he hit more against RHP, instead of Clark, CoJack's uninspiring OPS+ (for a first baseman) might've further declined. That's not to say Conor wont get better, only that his MLB service to date has been a testament to his low salary more than to position specific value. His limited skill set is quite easy to replace; at his salary not so much. It's nothing personal, but in my book Conor doesnt  earn "hero" or "unsung" points just because the Dbacks are too cheap to pursue a league average first baseman.

by Diamondhacks on Nov 28, 2007 11:49 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Then I'm a fascist
Because that's obviously what it must be when someone disagrees with you.  I'm a fascist of criminal proportions because I don't think that Bryan Price is the unsung hero of the team.  You happy now?

BRYAN PRICE IS MY LORD AND SAVIOUR.  He's just not my unsung hero.

I remember now why I never respond to any of your posts.  It's like talking to levski.  Fine - I'm wrong, you're right.  Now I can go back to my quiet offseason and you can go back to your Jerry Colangelo plushy doll and tell him what an idiot we all are.

Bob Melvin Sucks

by nihil67 on Nov 29, 2007 10:04 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Good Grief
I dont think you're a fascist, per se, and contrary to your wild suggestion, I've never labeled anyone else "who disagrees with me" a fascist. It's obviously a loaded word, one I selected to a) characterize some of your less than inspired "argumentation" and b) to further piss you off, after getting unnecessarily fussy with me about "criminal oversight" and an earnest attempt to spread some o' that Unsung Love to include Price.  

I gather "criminal oversight", which wasnt directed at you or anyone in particular, is what set you off. I'll take responsibility if my hyperbole or "humor" is too subtle - but with respect Ben, this isnt one of those times. "Criminal" was an obvious exaggeration, at the end of a substantitive argument, to elicit a chuckle, nothing more.  

I'm a fascist of criminal proportions because I don't think that Bryan Price is the unsung hero of the team.

No, but you often dismiss viewpoints rather abruptly (ie this sux or that sux or he's an idiot, without much to back it up), instead of genuinely engaging/rebutting views. While that  suppression could technically be termed " fascistic", a friendlier term, with less baggage, might be "annoying".

As I suggested, one thing that set me off is that you've been maniacally pounding home  causation between Bob Melvin and team performance, yet when I make a pedestrian case for Price, you immediately allege coaching influence isnt "knowable" - to suggest Price is somehow less worthy of consideration here. I see your metaphysical point and gladly acknowledged it, but your eagerness to make the point now, and use it to rather abruptly dismiss Price, suggests a motive here other than divining the truth and/or having a civil discussion.  

Happy Holidays!

by Diamondhacks on Nov 30, 2007 8:14 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the AZ SnakePit, the SB Nation blog about the Arizona Diamondbacks. Summer in Phoenix: "Would you like to sit on the porch? Or would you rather live?" -- Eddie Izzard.
Start posting about the Diamondbacks »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

39135485-59af19dbb26654095f910f34176af094_4ae8a81e-scaled_small
Predictions Group
Mrsnakepit_small
[OT]: Oscar nominations
Square-watermelon_small
Dana Eveland DFAed
Bmurph_small
Spring Fest 2010 - Vote for the Date
Beachrosei_small
Eric Byrnes a Mariner
Up_small
All Dbacks SGA bobbleheads
Cimg0181_small
How do you mend a broken sports heart?
Small
In-Depth Scouting Report (pitchers)
Ilikemony_small
I'm going through baseball withdrawls... and it's a month till pitchers and catchers report...
Golden_dome_small
Part 2 - A Retrospective Look at the Trade History of Josh Byrnes

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Manager

Mrsnakepit_small Jim McLennan

Bench coaches

Me_-_sp_studio_small snakecharmer

Gadsden_small DbacksSkins

Players

82283_small kishi

Meow2_small Azreous

Bmurph_small soco

Ilikemony_small Zephon

Keith_haring2_small Sprankton

Golden_dome_small IHateSouthBend