Here's a tremendous article about Justin Upton by ESPN.

ESPN Article

If you read the article, does it change your views on Upton in any way?

I've been advocate for keeping Upton, since I believe that the thumb injury he sustained messed with the mechanics of his swing, but he's been more patient at the plate (just look at his BB%). As I said before, they only trade I would make for Upton would be for Rangers 3B Mike Olt, and a middle infielder. But that's it.