Piecoro: D-Backs reality check

With their five most-coveted free agents set to depart and the Diamondbacks left to peruse the discount aisle of free agency, the harsh realities are hard to ignore, as are the tough questions that accompany them.

Here's one: Will the Diamondbacks be better next year?

Before that, let's start with the big picture: In the grand scheme, the club is in pretty good shape in terms of being a competitive team now and remaining one for years to come.

about 3 years ago unnamedDBacksfan 4 comments 0 recs |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Nicky P. is right.

We’re looking at a tough situation this coming year.

At least expectations will begin low.

"If the government's nuclear football ever were to fall into the wrong hands, Chris Horton would be called upon to intercept it on behalf of the Pentagon." -Kissing Suzy Kolber

by DbacksSkins on Nov 24, 2008 4:35 PM EST reply actions

I think Nick is right

in suggesting the Dbacks’ margin for error is fairly narrow right now, in terms of winning the division. It’s doable (LA wasnt exactly world beaters last year – 84 wins in a terrible division), but their young stars appear to be, in aggregate, better and younger than ours, and we’ve failed (so far) to collectively compensate for significant losses (Hudson, Cruz, Johnson, Lyon and Dunn).

In terms of just being “competitive” or “respectable”, the Dbacks should be that. In this division, with the young, existing core, that cant reasonably be avoided.

by Diamondhacks on Nov 24, 2008 9:16 PM EST reply actions

It appears they will need many of the following things to happen:
• Webb, Haren and Drew must remain elite performers.

I think the first two out of those three are very likely to happen – they have enough of a . It’d be nice to see Drew maintain the same level as did last season, and it’s certainly possible he will, but I can’t say I am assured of it with the same confidence as Webb and Haren.

• Young, Upton, Mark Reynolds and reliever Tony Pena must improve.

They all have youth on their side, so age and experience should help. Upton, in particular, should make a very large stride forward, I think. Can Reynolds cut back on the K’s? Should be a little better there, I think, and Pena probably too. Young, however, I have a feeling, we are getting about what we are going to from him.

• Right-hander Max Scherzer must make a seamless transition to a full-time starter.

His starts last season gave a good bit of grounds for optimism there, I think. He should be fine.

• Outfielder Eric Byrnes, first baseman Chad Tracy and reliever Jon Rauch must rebound and recover.

This is, I think, the key question, and I just don’t know. Surely Rauch – who basically cost us the title by going 0-6 – won’t be so bad, nor Byrnes as dreadful as he was? And Tracy, while always a platoon guy, should be finally fully recovered? But I can’t say I am feeling tremendously certain on any of these front. I’m hoping for the best, but preparing for the worst…

by Jim McLennan on Nov 24, 2008 10:25 PM EST reply actions

His starts last season gave a good bit of grounds for optimism there, I think. He should be fine.

So long as he’s not as injury-prone as some worry, yeah.

"If the government's nuclear football ever were to fall into the wrong hands, Chris Horton would be called upon to intercept it on behalf of the Pentagon." -Kissing Suzy Kolber

by DbacksSkins on Nov 25, 2008 1:20 PM EST up reply actions