AZ Snakepit: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Steve McNair Dead - Former NFL QB Shot and Killed


The 2008 'Pitties: Rookie of the year nominees

With the SB Nation network working towards the announcement of their Rookie of the Year award at the end of this week, it seems an appropriate time for us to focus on the Arizona candidates, and announce the nominees for the next in the 2008 'Pitties - the Diamondbacks Rookie of the Year. Let's be honest: there really isn't much of a competition here, and so, in the interests of promoting discussion, I'm just as interested to see which of the overall National League contenders (Soto, Jurrjens, etc.) you think are deserving of the award. Feel free to post your 1-2-3 in the comments and we'll see how they compare with my and Charmer's choices on Friday.

Anyway, the Arizona nominees are only three in number. There were various others who also made their debut for us this year [Jailen Peguero, Jamie D'Antona, etc.] but all of them will retain their rookie status for 2009 - as far as I can tell, I don't think Billy Buckner spent 45 days on the roster before they expanded at the start of September. The trio listed below will not be so eligible, making this in all three cases, their definitive rookie season. They're listed in alphabetical order.

Alex Romero. The 24-year old Romero made his debut on Opening Day, pinch-hitting for Tony Peña in the ninth, and laying down a successful sacrifice bunt. His inclusion on the roster was a surprise, as he beat out veteran Trot Nixon for the final, left-handed spot on the bench after hitting .316 during spring training. He was sent down in late April, but the loss of Byrnes saw him recalled, and he spent the rest of the season with the major-league club, appearing in 78 games and getting 28 starts, the great majority of them in right. His offense was light, batting only .230, but his only home-run, on July 21, broke up a Rich Harden no-hitter in the sixth inning and was crucial in helping Arizona to a 2-0 win. The highlight of his year was, however, his game-saving catch against the Padres, which won the 2008 'Pittie for Play of the Year, getting a clear majority of votes in our recent poll.

Leo Rosales. Though pitching only 30 innings, Rosales loses his rookie status under the 45-day rule, coming up from Tucson to make his debut on June 15, and staying with the team almost the entire rest of the way. He was used mainly in blowouts, with the majority of his appearances when the margin was three runs or more. Our record was 6-21 in games Rosales was used, but he only appeared six times while we were leading. He picked up his first career win on July 3rd, pitching a scoreless ninth against Milwaukee and benefiting from our memorable six-run comeback in the bottom half of the inning. His only other decision came in his last game, pitching the sixth in an eventual 12-3 clobbering by St. Louis, but an ERA+ of 108 in his rookie year, is nothing to be ashamed of.

Max Scherzer. Our heterochromatically-eyed pitcher entered with a bang, retiring all 13 batters he faced on April 29, seven of them by strikeout. He replaced Edgar Gonzalez in the rotation, making his first start six days later, but taking the loss in an 11-4 defeat by the Phillies - though most of the runs came after he had left the game. He seemed almost cursed: the team won just twice when he pitched, and the scores when he came into those games were 11-1 and 8-3! He ended the season with a record of 0-4, but struck out 66 in just 56 innings, a K/9 ratio that ranked 12th among the 318 pitchers in the majors with 50+ IP. His best outing was likely the September 14 appearance against the Reds, where he two-hit them over six innings, with nine strikeouts, yet ended with a no-decision. Shame we didn't get to see a playoff against the Dodgers with its hypothetical Scherzer-Kershaw match-up.

Poll
Who was the 2008 Diamondbacks Rookie of the Year?
Alex Romero
13 votes
Leo Rosales
5 votes
Max Scherzer
62 votes

80 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs | Comment 3 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Making outs 75% of the time won't do

Romero had a homer to break up a no no and helped win a game, and made one helluva catch one night in San Diego to preserve another win. But he made out 75% of the time, and all those outs contributed to losses too. There are no “intangibles” that can make up for that OBP. Oh yeah…….that sac bunt he had on opening day…….was one of two he had all year. So much for him doing “all the little things”……..all of which he did too little of.

Scherzer pitched really well….but the team never scored……or won……when he started. But he performed at a high level most of the time. There really is no contest who was the better player in 2008.

For a 27 year old mop up man with nearly a 1.6 WHIP, Rosales wasn’t bad. ;)

by shoewizard on Oct 15, 2008 2:01 AM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Pardon me

For trying to install some excitement in what is, basically, a one-horse race. :-) No kidding on the run-support for Scherzer: 2.25 over his seven starts. That’s positively Johnson-esque…

by Jim McLennan on Oct 15, 2008 11:24 AM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Sorry to pee on the poll

Didn’t mean to be a killjoy.

Romero might still turn out to be a useful utility outfielder. But he has to stop hacking at everything thrown up there. That worked in Tucson and he had a nice BA, which kept his OBP afloat. But looking at his minor league career and the stroke he exhibited in the majors, he doesn’t really have much if any power, so he’ll have to find a way to be more selective and patient going forward or his career will be short and brutish. It’s pretty tough for a guy to change his stripes at this juncture.

by shoewizard on Oct 15, 2008 12:40 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the AZ SnakePit, the SB Nation blog about the Arizona Diamondbacks. Summer in Phoenix: "Would you like to sit on the porch? Or would you rather live?" -- Eddie Izzard.
Start posting about the Diamondbacks »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

63797e89c433_small
With Byrnes out...And Young ehhhhh
Square-watermelon_small
Why are TC and Byrnes still playing?
Square-watermelon_small
Trade Qualls?
Not_batman_small
Tucson Snakepit Meetup?
Rfc_small
A little help from my friends... (D-Backs Fancast)
Small
OT 4th of July Wallpaper
Ztjinwtp_small
One positive to this dismal season
Picture_3_small
Lopez wants to stay in Arizona
Beartato-cheerupface_small
Diamondbacks 0, Royals 5: Complete Embarrassment
Small
Dbacks Draft Breakdown Show

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Manager

Mrsnakepit_small Jim McLennan

Bench coaches

Me_-_sp_studio_small snakecharmer

Gadsden_small DbacksSkins

Players

Image-00002301_small kishi

Meow2_small Azreous

Romy3_small soco

Mlp_small dahlian

Official Partner of Yahoo! Sports